“You’d have to kill me to get this jacket off,” Austin Butler’s Benny says with a smirk as the opening scene of Jeff Nichols’ film plays out. Speaking with the project’s costume designer, we delve into the relationship between community, independence, and fashion — and why the bikers would die for their colours.
In 1967, photographer Danny Lyon published a book titled The Bikeriders, in which he documented the lives of the Chicago Outlaws Motorcycle Club. For four years, the author joined the group as they travelled America, taking photographs and interviewing the members — before compiling all he had accumulated into one body of work full of striking black-and-white images, first hand stories, and a true sense of the humanity and community at the heart of a motorcycle club in the sixties.
Over half a century later, Mike Faist steps into the role of Lyons himself in a fictionalised account of the makeshift chosen family, renamed to the Vandals MC for Jeff Nichols’ film The Bikeriders. Starring Austin Butler, Jodie Comer, and Tom Hardy alongside Faist, the movie chronicles the formation and evolution of the club — as it morphs from a safe space for outcasts such as the young, mischievous Benny (Butler) to something much more frightening for him, his wife Kathy (Comer), the founder Johnny (Hardy), and the rest of the group. Told through interviews and flashback scenes, the faux-documentary pulls visuals and narratives directly from its namesake, with a level of believability profound for such an action-filled drama.
One of the most crucial parts to get right in order to achieve such authenticity was the costume design, for which Nichols tapped his previous collaborator Erin Benach to work her magic. And connecting with her over Zoom two weeks before the premiere to talk about the nuances of personalising motorcycle jackets, using styles to showcase a decade passing, and the process of ageing fabric, it is clear why she was the perfect designer for the job.
“I got into film because I loved looking at people and seeing what they wear and interpreting it for psychology,” she tells me from a sunlit room as we talk about the Vandals’ uniform and the coexisting needs for belonging and independence that run through the duration of the film. The bikeriders, many of whom were cast out of their families or struggled to fit in with society, were innately individualised people – though craved a feeling of community provided to them by the club.
“The movie is very much about finding your identity through your group of people. A lot of these guys found each other because they couldn’t fit into the other square box of the time. It wasn’t just about violence, it was about a time in history where they were trying to figure out a different prescription to live. And the pinkos [preppy, straight-edged foils to the Vandals], the bikeriders, all these people in the world were using their clothing to express themselves.”
There is arguably no better visual representation of this dynamic as with the motorcycle jackets, decorated with the Vandals’ “colours” – serving as a symbol of allegiance and affiliation, placing its wearer as part of a pack, and promising safety and community in exchange for loyalty.
For the film, it was Benach’s job to delve into the psyche of each character and understand just how they would customise their motorcycle uniform, hand-making each biker’s patches and details just as they would have done themselves. “Each of the people would do it in a different way,” she explained. “We needed to make like 200 of those vests and they couldn’t look alike. You couldn’t have a factory do it or manufacture it, you need to just do it yourself in house.”
“Really the challenge was to find the characters within the uniform — and that’s the way I did it,” she continued. For Cal, who builds carburettors and bike engines, his vest needed to reflect his skilled craftsmanship — so featured sewed edges, a careful placement of his Gak, and extra detail-oriented precision. Zipco, in contrast, is from Latvia and wore a “Euro version” of the uniform. He didn’t have a denim cut, putting his ‘colours’ directly onto the leather jacket.
Johnny, the leader of the Vandals, is a bit older and more traditional than other members of the club. He works as a truck driver during the day and comes home to his wife and children every evening. His look, therefore, was heavily influenced by the 50s silhouette. And then there’s Benny — whose nonchalance and ambivalence needed to be reflected in what he wore. For his leather jacket, which was worn in enough to seem slept in, his ‘colours’ weren’t even cut out. “It was meant to look ‘un-thought out’ and not trying at all.”
Achieving such a nonchalant look, however, required hours and hours of work. “I think to be able to make all of the clothing look and feel the way I read the script to be, it just needed so much grease and dust and dirt and mud and I was excited to do that, to get into that. That part of the process — the ageing and dying process of what we do in our world — is really hard actually. It’s a hard thing to make something look old that is new and to do it in a way that doesn’t look fake.” From overdyeing everything with a greenish, bluish dye to throwing it all in a dryer with rocks, sanding it, airbrushing it with dirt, and painting mud on top, it was an eight step process to get one pair of jeans fit for the camera.
At some points, Benach lifted looks directly from Lyon’s images — dissecting the photographed garments and hypothesising any missing details. “When Benny is in his sleeveless black shirt leaning over the table in the bar… that was a moment Jeff [Nichols] wanted to recreate literally. I always find that challenge to be really fun. From a technical standpoint, you have to figure out which fabric it is, how it drapes, and how it does the same things you’re trying to recreate in the image. And then, of course, there’s all the blank information that you need to fill in.”
“For a long time, I had no idea what Benny’s bottom half looked like, because it’s not in any of the pictures. I was filling it in with research, but I really wanted to know, because it was at a time in the 60s where it could have gone different ways — it could have been a little baggier, it could have been a little tighter, it could have been shorter, it could have been cuffed. And then Danny Lyons sent Jeff a picture that is not published anywhere and it answered my question. I could see his jeans perfectly.”
In other instances, Benach used costume to drive home narratives and plot. “One of the important story points is that at a certain point, the group got so big, it got so out of hand, that you wanted to start to feel like it had lost that uniformity and specificity — and started to feel like all the other chapters. So as we got into the late 60s and early 70s, silhouettes started to change.”
One scene that painted a jarring picture of how the community changed revolved around a red dress. At a Vandals house party, Kathy – whose wardrobe remained more or less consistent throughout the years – spotted another woman in a striking red dress, and ultimately found herself wearing it. But when the older members disperse to break up a fight outside, she is attacked and assaulted by the newer cohort.
Utilising the dress — or rather, the men’s reaction to the dress on Kathy — as a means to highlight the shift in the Vandals and the new tier of violence that came with it, the costume design had to be just right. “Kathy as a person was not a very flowy fabric, feminine character. I knew that it needed to be something that Kathy was intrigued by. We all have our fashion moments where we’re like, ‘oh, that thing is cool,’ and so I was trying to get in the mind of Kathy.” After three different versions, she struck gold with a 1970s take on the 60s mod dress — something just out of Kathy’s comfort zone to warrant her intrigue without feeling disconnected from her typical style and identity.
As Benach reached into the characters’ inner selves to build out their wardrobes, the actors used their costumes as a means to get into characters – creating a collaborative and cyclical dynamic between the cast and crew. As she recalls her early fittings with Comer that brought Kathy to life, she reflects on what it means to work with such an open and creative team: “As soon as we started, with the first few outfits, Jodie immediately changed the way she walked and held her shoulders. She put her hips forward and found the stance, the posture. And then I react off of that.” She pauses. “[The Bikeriders] is my third film with [Jeff Nichols] and it’s always been very collaborative.”
“Sometimes half the battle is just the trust — whether it’s the actor, the director, the producers.” For this film, there was certainly plenty. “I feel very grateful that I now have years behind me that I spend less energy on trying to gain trust and more on just being creative.”
The result? A wardrobe full of pieces that come straight from the psyche of their characters, that reflect outcasts’ longing feelings to belong, years of pride for a chosen family, and a vibrant community that turned dark in front of their eyes. Benach weaved the characters’ identities into their fabrics, provided mediums for the actors to connect with their roles, and created an innate interconnectedness that made Benny – when under threat from a rival gang – declare he’d rather die than take his jacket off and give up his colours.
Related → Related → Related → Related → Related → Related → Related → Related → Related → Related → Related → Related → Related → Related → Related → Related → Related → Related → Related → Related →